Argument Analysis

 Use this format when analyzing columns

What is the “hot topic?”

What is the writer’s position?

How did you determine his/her position?

Can you identify the “thesis statement?”

How many “supports” were offered?

What type?
statistics with citations:
beginning with a simple, undeniable statement and building logically:
anecdotal evidence:
combination of the above:
Other (describe).

Is mention made of any sort of argument that disagrees with the writer’s position?

How is it handled?

How is the piece “wrapped up?”

Was it convincing?

Did you spot examples of “rotten reasoning” and if so what were they?